The Questionable Death of a Deputy’s Girlfriend Michelle O’Connell by Autumn’s Oddities

After a concert at the St. Augustine Amphitheater in 2010, Michelle O’Connell and Jeremy Banks headed home with some friends. Minutes after their friends left, Banks claims that Michelle found his service weapon and shot herself with it.

**Sponsor is Caraway Home
Use Discount Code crime for 10% off your order.

Subscribe to Autumn’s Oddities on iHeart –
Subscribe on Apple Podcasts –
Subscribe Everywhere else –

When St. John’s County Sheriff’s Office arrived on the scene, they recognized Banks as one of their very own deputies. This is another case where there was very little investigating done and extremely questionable circumstances surrounding a death.


Indie Drop-In
All content legally licensed from the original creator.

Thank you to Autumn’s Oddities for the great episode.
You can find Indie Drop-In at

Help Indie Drop-In support indie creators by buying us a coffee!

Brands can advertise on Indie Drop-In using Patreon


Any advertising found in this episode is inserted by Indie Drop-In and not endorsed by the Creator.

If you would like to have your show featured go to

#podcast #truecrime #toptruecrime #truecrimepodcast